Julie

Votre espace se prépare…

Preparing your space…

Le chargement prend plus de temps que prévu.
Réessayer
Loading is taking longer than expected.
Try again
Skip to main content

France and Switzerland

Shareholder refused reports before the annual meeting

In France, check which annual accounts or reports the shareholder may obtain under the applicable company rules and whether the sending conditions apply. In Switzerland, the management and audit reports must be available at least 20 days before the annual meeting. Match the actual refusal to the report and meeting date.

See the records to compare

Sources checked on

Choose the applicable law to prepare your question.

French law

Check the sequence of the French request and refusal

Fictional example
Date of meeting notice2026-09-07
Date the company received the request2026-09-15
Date of refusal2026-09-17
Annual meeting date2026-09-24

Use the dated sequence and the proof of receipt to match the exact report against the sending or inspection route.

Swiss law

Find the Swiss calendar point for access to annual reports

Fictional example
Date of the Swiss general meeting2026-09-24
Date you tested access to the report2026-09-08

The example meeting is on 24 September. The marker is 4 September. Keep the evidence showing whether the annual reports could actually be read then.

Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.

French law

Which SA meeting and annual report are identified in the notice?

Check that the issuer is a French SA and that the notice identifies the annual ordinary meeting, the accounting period and the business of approving the accounts. Ask for the management or auditor’s report specified for that meeting, where it exists. Article L225-115 identifies relevant categories of shareholder documents.

French Commercial Code, article L225-115, SA meeting information

Which shareholding evidence and dated transmission request qualify?

Keep evidence of registered shares or the required account evidence for qualifying bearer holdings. Note when the company received the request. Under article R225-88 the sending request is available from convocation through the fifth day inclusive before the meeting, for the documents named by the provision.

French Commercial Code, article R225-88, sending documents on request

Was the exact report available online or for inspection in the required period?

Check that the actual requested report, for the right year, can be found by the stated means. Under R225-89, the annual meeting has a consultation and copy route at the registered office or administrative headquarters, with a defined fifteen-day window for the auditor’s report. Website publication can affect the separate sending duty under R225-88.

French Commercial Code, article R225-89, inspection and copies

Which unavailable document supports a request for disclosure under L238-1?

Identify precisely which covered report you could not obtain and attach the request, proof of delivery and refusal or evidence of failed access. Article L238-1 allows a qualifying request to the tribunal president in urgent proceedings for an order communicating the document, potentially with a penalty, or for a representative to provide it.

French Commercial Code, article L238-1, urgent document disclosure

Swiss law

Which management or audit report should have been accessible?

For the Swiss meeting, identify the management report and the audit report or reports for the financial year under consideration. Article 699a calls for these reports to be accessible to shareholders. Match the stated file title and reporting period to the meeting notice.

Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 699a and 697–697b, annual reports and other shareholder rights

What date is twenty days before the actual meeting?

Use the actual general meeting date, including any documented change, and count back 20 days. Article 699a requires access at least 20 days before the meeting. For the worksheet’s fictional 24 September meeting, the calendar marker is 4 September. Compare this with the first evidenced day of real access.

Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 699a and 697–697b, annual reports and other shareholder rights

Was timely electronic access real or did the shareholder need delivery?

Test the actual link and keep a dated note of the file offered or any access error. Where the reports cannot be accessed electronically, article 699a allows a shareholder to demand timely delivery. Specify the missing report, shareholder status and the relevant meeting when contacting the company.

Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 699a and 697–697b, annual reports and other shareholder rights

Which communication documents the failure?

Keep the dated delivery request, the notice and any refusal or instruction to use another address. Record whether the company supplied a usable replacement link before the meeting. The timeline should show each attempt to obtain the exact report and what the shareholder actually received.

Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 699a and 697–697b, annual reports and other shareholder rights

Does a separate request concern general records or information rather than these annual reports?

Separate the annual-report access issue from a request for other company books, records or information. Articles 697 to 697b have their own conditions. Article 699a also addresses certain post-meeting delivery requests. Identify the record sought and the stage before applying a procedural deadline.

Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 699a and 697–697b, annual reports and other shareholder rights

Common questions

France — Which shareholding evidence and dated transmission request qualify?

Keep evidence of registered shares or the required account evidence for qualifying bearer holdings. Note when the company received the request. Under article R225-88 the sending request is available from convocation through the fifth day inclusive before the meeting, for the documents named by the provision.

France — Was the exact report available online or for inspection in the required period?

Check that the actual requested report, for the right year, can be found by the stated means. Under R225-89, the annual meeting has a consultation and copy route at the registered office or administrative headquarters, with a defined fifteen-day window for the auditor’s report. Website publication can affect the separate sending duty under R225-88.

France — Which unavailable document supports a request for disclosure under L238-1?

Identify precisely which covered report you could not obtain and attach the request, proof of delivery and refusal or evidence of failed access. Article L238-1 allows a qualifying request to the tribunal president in urgent proceedings for an order communicating the document, potentially with a penalty, or for a representative to provide it.

Switzerland — Which management or audit report should have been accessible?

For the Swiss meeting, identify the management report and the audit report or reports for the financial year under consideration. Article 699a calls for these reports to be accessible to shareholders. Match the stated file title and reporting period to the meeting notice.

General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.