France and Switzerland
New share issue removes subscription rights
In France, check the actual resolution, the share tranche and the reports required for disapplying preferential subscription rights. In Switzerland, restricting or excluding the right requires important reasons and must avoid unjustified advantage or disadvantage. Compare the proposed allocation and issue terms with the existing rights before deciding how to respond.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Calculate the French proportional baseline for the affected tranche
| Number of newly issued shares in the French tranche | 10000 |
|---|---|
| Existing participation used for comparison (%) | 5 |
The fictional holder’s 5% of a 10,000-share tranche corresponds to 500 shares before the proposed exclusion. Ask how the resolution treats that baseline.
Swiss law
Estimate the Swiss holder’s proportional subscription baseline
| New shares covered by the proposal | 10000 |
|---|---|
| Existing participation on the relevant basis (%) | 5 |
The reference is 500 shares in the example. Compare it with the proposed allocation, the stated reason and the pricing terms.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
What cash tranche does the draft exclude from the preferential right? | Identify the resolution number and the cash shares offered in the affected tranche. Under French article L225-135 the general meeting can suppress the right for the whole issue or a tranche within the applicable procedure. Record the quantity and price or pricing method for that specific part. French Commercial Code, article L225-135, suppression of a preferential right |
Who is named as beneficiary and what does the board report say? | Read the beneficiary details and the board or management report together. Note the purpose of the issue, why the exclusion is proposed and how it is allocated. Article R225-114 addresses these disclosures for the applicable offering branch. A named buyer and a category of eligible buyers call for different records. French Commercial Code, article R225-114, management report disclosures |
Which allocation and pricing evidence is missing? | Look for the number allocated, the price or its determination, and the stated effect on existing interests under the conditions of article R225-115. Compare the actual draft and accompanying reports. Specify whether the omission concerns the price basis, recipient allocation, effect on your holding or a relevant report. French Commercial Code, article R225-115, effect of the issue on existing holdings |
If a named beneficiary already holds shares, which voting treatment requires checking? | If the resolution reserves the issue for a named beneficiary, establish whether that party holds shares. French article L225-138 excludes the named beneficiary from the vote and removes its shares for the quorum and majority calculation. Preserve the proposed voting record and identify the beneficiary’s holdings. French Commercial Code, article L225-138, reserved issue and vote |
Swiss law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
What proportional entitlement would the existing shareholding ordinarily represent? | Use the existing participation shown in the shareholder records to calculate a reference share of the new issue. Article 652b gives a proportionate right. Apply the percentage to the actual tranche under review and record the share class and nominal basis needed before interpreting any fractional outcome. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 652b and 652e, subscription rights and the board report |
Which stated reason is offered for restricting or suppressing the right? | Identify the important reason actually proposed for restricting or suppressing the right, such as what the issuer says it must achieve through the allocation. Article 652b requires important reasons. Ask what evidence connects the excluded tranche and named allocation to that stated purpose. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 652b and 652e, subscription rights and the board report |
Who receives the excluded shares and why is the treatment justified? | Compare the allocation and pricing terms for recipients and existing holders. Article 652b bars unjustified advantage or disadvantage through the restriction or exclusion and through issue pricing. A difference needs to be examined in context, with the purpose and terms of the offer. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 652b and 652e, subscription rights and the board report |
What do the draft, price and eventual capital report show? | Separate what the draft authorises and what the board’s subsequent capital increase report establishes. Article 652e calls for written information on compliance with any restriction or exclusion and the use of relevant unexercised or withdrawn rights. Keep documents for both the proposed and executed steps. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 652b and 652e, subscription rights and the board report |
What should be resolved before the vote rather than assumed from the issue documents? | Ask before the vote what part of your reference allocation would be removed, what price the beneficiaries pay and why this is justified. Include the draft clause and calculations. After execution, compare the board’s account of how the restriction and rights were handled with the agreed resolution. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 652b and 652e, subscription rights and the board report |
Common questions
France — Who is named as beneficiary and what does the board report say?
Read the beneficiary details and the board or management report together. Note the purpose of the issue, why the exclusion is proposed and how it is allocated. Article R225-114 addresses these disclosures for the applicable offering branch. A named buyer and a category of eligible buyers call for different records.
France — Which allocation and pricing evidence is missing?
Look for the number allocated, the price or its determination, and the stated effect on existing interests under the conditions of article R225-115. Compare the actual draft and accompanying reports. Specify whether the omission concerns the price basis, recipient allocation, effect on your holding or a relevant report.
France — If a named beneficiary already holds shares, which voting treatment requires checking?
If the resolution reserves the issue for a named beneficiary, establish whether that party holds shares. French article L225-138 excludes the named beneficiary from the vote and removes its shares for the quorum and majority calculation. Preserve the proposed voting record and identify the beneficiary’s holdings.
Switzerland — What proportional entitlement would the existing shareholding ordinarily represent?
Use the existing participation shown in the shareholder records to calculate a reference share of the new issue. Article 652b gives a proportionate right. Apply the percentage to the actual tranche under review and record the share class and nominal basis needed before interpreting any fractional outcome.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.