France and Switzerland
Exclude one asset from the contractual community
In France, compare the expressly negotiated exclusion with the existing title and the rules for property already separate by nature. In Switzerland, the marriage contract can exclude specified assets or categories, with a default rule for their income. Record the asset, clause and income treatment before reviewing the proposed agreement.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
What remains unclear about the rental property’s exclusion?
| Title and clause identifying the excluded property | Title and exclusion identified |
|---|---|
| Wording about income, proceeds and replacement property | Wording still needs review |
The example identifies the rental property and excludes it expressly. The treatment of rent, future sale proceeds and any replacement asset still needs checking in the draft.
Swiss law
Does the Swiss draft also address income from the excluded assets?
| Identified securities and exclusion clause | Assets and clause identified |
|---|---|
| Income and proceeds treatment in the draft | Income or proceeds treatment uncertain |
The example excludes listed securities. The next check is any express change to the Article 224 treatment of income and the wording on sale or replacement assets.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
is the asset already separate by nature or is the draft making a specific contractual variation?
Check if the French asset is already separate by nature under Article 1404. Identify the statutory category or the specific contractual variation the draft makes.
French Civil Code, Art. 1404what does the universal-community or other applicable clause actually say about this asset?
Read the French universal-community clause and any express exclusion. Article 1526 defines its ordinary scope, including treatment of naturally separate assets.
French Civil Code, Art. 1526Which specific asset and title documents identify the property in the draft?
For the French draft, match the asset reference, title and origin documents to the exclusion. Check whether the clause selects the same property.
French Civil Code, Art. 1497What property community would otherwise apply under the proposed agreement?
Read the French agreement’s proposed community regime and identify what would include the property without the particular variation.
French Civil Code, Art. 1497What question about the current version should the notary settle before signature?
Ask the French notary to verify the exact clause, asset and unresolved wording on income or proceeds before the current version is signed.
French Civil Code, Art. 1497Swiss law
what property or class does the agreement exclude under art. 224?
Identify the specific Swiss asset or class excluded from community. Compare the wording with the ownership and asset identification evidence.
Swiss Civil Code, Arts. 182, 184 and 224 (SR 210)does the draft expressly change the default for income from that asset?
Under Swiss Article 224, income from an excluded asset also remains outside the community unless agreed otherwise. Check the draft for that different agreement.
Swiss Civil Code, Arts. 182, 184 and 224 (SR 210)What does each clause actually say about replacement property, liabilities or third parties?
For the Swiss agreement, read separately the provisions for sale proceeds, replacement assets and related obligations. Identify which third-party rights the documents actually discuss.
Swiss Civil Code, Arts. 182, 184 and 224 (SR 210)Common questions
What property community would otherwise apply under the proposed agreement?
Read the French agreement’s proposed community regime and identify what would include the property without the particular variation.
France: is the asset already separate by nature or is the draft making a specific contractual variation?
Check if the French asset is already separate by nature under Article 1404. Identify the statutory category or the specific contractual variation the draft makes.
France: what does the universal-community or other applicable clause actually say about this asset?
Read the French universal-community clause and any express exclusion. Article 1526 defines its ordinary scope, including treatment of naturally separate assets.
Switzerland: what property or class does the agreement exclude under art. 224?
Identify the specific Swiss asset or class excluded from community. Compare the wording with the ownership and asset identification evidence.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.