France and Switzerland
Earlier court acts after a successful recusal
In France, Article 347 distinguishes earlier acts and particular decisions, using when the judge or court learned of the recusal ruling. In Switzerland, Article 51 deals with annulment and repetition after knowledge of the ground for recusal. List each act, who participated and the relevant date before choosing the remedy.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Which French acts occurred before the judge learned of recusal?
| Date of the act in issue | 2026-11-09 |
|---|---|
| Date of the recusal decision | 2026-11-10 |
| When the judge learned of the decision | 2026-11-12 |
The example records an act on 9 November, recusal granted on 10 November and notice to the judge on 12 November. Next check whether the act was procedural or came within the exception for an operative ruling.
Swiss law
Which Swiss dates support reviewing a particular earlier act?
| Act involving the person concerned | 2026-11-09 |
|---|---|
| Date the recusal ground became known | 2026-11-10 |
| Filing of the requested annulment or repetition | 2026-11-18 |
The fictional act took place on 9 November, the ground became known on 10 November and the request is dated 18 November. Check the supporting records for those dates and for the act that would need to be repeated.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
Which ruling granted recusal and which judge did it replace?
Identify the French order granting recusal and the affected judge or court. Record the replacement and which proceeding the order concerns.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 347When did the judge or court learn of that ruling?
Find evidence of when the French judge or court learned of the successful recusal decision. The filing and decision dates are separate events.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 347Which acts preceded that event, and which resolve all or part of the merits?
List the French acts before notice and read each operative ruling. Article 347 preserves earlier procedural acts in principle and treats rulings on all or part of the merits differently regardless of date.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 347Is any nonmerits decision provisionally enforceable?
Check whether a French nonmerits ruling was provisionally enforceable. Such rulings also fall within Article 347’s exception, so identify the exact operative decision.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 347Swiss law
Who participated in the challenged act?
Identify who took part in the Swiss act and in what capacity. Article 51 concerns acts in which the person required to recuse participated.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 51 (SR 272)What evidence fixes when the ground became known?
Find evidence of when the recusal ground became known. Article 51 gives ten days from knowledge of the ground for a party’s request to annul and repeat the affected acts.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 51 (SR 272)Which precise act was requested to be annulled or repeated?
Match the request to each Swiss procedural act it identifies. Include the act’s date, its author, the person’s participation and what is requested.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 51 (SR 272)Can the evidence be taken again?
Record whether the evidence can be taken again. Under Article 51, evidence that cannot be taken again can still be considered.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 51 (SR 272)Is the case still open or is a separate review branch in issue?
Check whether the Swiss proceedings are closed and another remedy remains. Article 51 provides a distinct review branch when the ground is found after closure and its conditions are met.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 51 (SR 272)Common questions
France — When did the judge or court learn of that ruling?
Find evidence of when the French judge or court learned of the successful recusal decision. The filing and decision dates are separate events.
France — Which acts preceded that event, and which resolve all or part of the merits?
List the French acts before notice and read each operative ruling. Article 347 preserves earlier procedural acts in principle and treats rulings on all or part of the merits differently regardless of date.
France — Is any nonmerits decision provisionally enforceable?
Check whether a French nonmerits ruling was provisionally enforceable. Such rulings also fall within Article 347’s exception, so identify the exact operative decision.
Switzerland — Who participated in the challenged act?
Identify who took part in the Swiss act and in what capacity. Article 51 concerns acts in which the person required to recuse participated.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.