France and Switzerland
A public decision-maker previously acted for a party
In France, compare the public employee’s prior role in the file with the act signed under a delegation and apply the statutory conflict test. In Swiss federal procedure, someone who acted for a party in the same matter must stand aside when preparing or making the decision. Identify the records of both roles.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Match the authority, delegation and prior work
| Earlier role and filed document | Q prepared S-3 for a party in A-11 |
|---|---|
| Later preparation and signature authority | Q prepared and signed an act under written delegation |
| Record of the request to step aside | Response and the body’s own procedure to verify |
Fictional file A-11. Compare Q’s earlier work for a party with the later preparation and delegated signature.
Swiss law
Map the same file to the federal recusal record
| Earlier mandate and filing | Q submitted S-3 for a party in A-11 |
|---|---|
| Later role in the decision | Q listed among those preparing the decision |
| Recusal request and deciding body | Written objection on file, ruling and attendance to verify |
Fictional example. Q appears in a party submission and later in decision preparation. Establish who ruled on the written recusal dispute.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
Which administrative officer’s recusal was refused?
Identify officer Q and obtain the document responding to the request to step aside, if one exists. The French impartiality duty in article L121-1 applies to the public agent. Confirm who actually prepared or signed the contested act.
French General Public Service Code, art. L121-1What earlier role is documented?
Read submission S-3 and identify the party, mandate and file reference. The French conflict test under article L121-5 concerns an interference capable of influencing or appearing to influence impartial, independent and objective performance. Connect the prior work to actual duties.
French General Public Service Code, art. L121-5Did the officer participate in the same decision?
Compare the preparation record, written signing delegation and signed act. If an agent considers that they have a conflict while holding delegated signing authority, article L122-1 requires that authority to go unused. Confirm the capacity in which Q signed.
French General Public Service Code, art. L122-1Which procedure governs this particular authority?
Identify the body’s own procedural rules and whether Q was acting under a delegation or on a panel. Article L122-1 sets role-dependent responses. Establish the decision-maker and applicable route for the particular body.
French General Public Service Code, art. L122-1Swiss law
What earlier work was done for a party?
Identify the filing Q prepared or submitted for a party and confirm the same matter through file A-11. Article 10(1)(c) addresses earlier representation or action for a party in the same matter.
Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 10Did the officer prepare or make the decision?
Collect the later drafting assignment, meeting record or signed decision. In Swiss federal procedure, article 10 applies to those who make or prepare decisions. Both the earlier role and later participation matter.
Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 10Who resolved the recusal dispute?
Keep the written recusal request, date of disclosure and decision on the objection. A disputed recusal under article 10(2) goes to the supervisory authority or the collegiate body, with the affected member absent where that body decides.
Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 10Which records establish the two roles?
Pair S-3 with the decision-preparation record and keep the recusal ruling. Article 29 supports fair treatment in administrative proceedings. Check the actual procedure and article 10 scope before relying on a particular recusal route.
Swiss Federal Constitution, art. 29Common questions
France: What earlier role is documented?
Read submission S-3 and identify the party, mandate and file reference. The French conflict test under article L121-5 concerns an interference capable of influencing or appearing to influence impartial, independent and objective performance. Connect the prior work to actual duties.
France: Did the officer participate in the same decision?
Compare the preparation record, written signing delegation and signed act. If an agent considers that they have a conflict while holding delegated signing authority, article L122-1 requires that authority to go unused. Confirm the capacity in which Q signed.
France: Which procedure governs this particular authority?
Identify the body’s own procedural rules and whether Q was acting under a delegation or on a panel. Article L122-1 sets role-dependent responses. Establish the decision-maker and applicable route for the particular body.
Switzerland: What earlier work was done for a party?
Identify the filing Q prepared or submitted for a party and confirm the same matter through file A-11. Article 10(1)(c) addresses earlier representation or action for a party in the same matter.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.