France and Switzerland
A permit withdrawn on a different factual ground
For a covered French withdrawal of an existing permit, compare the stated factual ground with the material you could address before the decision. In Swiss federal procedure, the right to be heard ordinarily applies before the authority decides, subject to statutory exceptions. Preserve the missing opportunity to respond alongside the signed decision.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Compare the stated ground with the French prior notice
| Operative permit date | 2026-10-12 |
|---|---|
| Prior notice date | 2026-11-11 |
| Withdrawal decision date | 2026-11-17 |
| Issue communicated before withdrawal | Processing concern involving permit A-41 |
| Final reason and response opportunity | Incident P-17, no opportunity on that point recorded |
Fictional example. Record when the holder was told about P-17 and whether the file shows an opportunity to respond.
Swiss law
Trace the hearing record in the Swiss federal file
| Permit date | 2026-10-12 |
|---|---|
| Date of earlier notice | 2026-11-11 |
| Withdrawal date | 2026-11-17 |
| Fact described in the prior notice | Processing concern concerning A-41 |
| Decisive fact and evidence of prior hearing | Incident P-17, invitation about the incident not located |
Fictional example. Compare the 11 November notice with the 17 November decision and identify the missing evidence about P-17.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
Which operative approval was withdrawn? | Find permit A-41 dated 12 October and the paragraph of the withdrawal ending its effect. French article L211-2 covers the withdrawal or repeal of rights-conferring decisions. Check the original permit’s scope and operative status. French Code on Relations Between the Public and the Administration, art. L211-2 |
What factual ground does the decision give? | In the example, the notice concerns a processing issue and the final decision relies on incident P-17. Record the difference and when P-17 was disclosed. For a covered withdrawal, this matters to the opportunity for prior submissions. French Code on Relations Between the Public and the Administration, art. L121-1 |
Was there a chance to give written observations? | Read the invitation to respond, the date received and the actual deadline. Under article L122-1, where applicable, the holder has an opportunity for written observations and in relevant cases may request oral observations. French Code on Relations Between the Public and the Administration, art. L122-1 |
Is a statutory exception or special procedure identified? | Identify the stated exception and its legal basis. French article L121-2 provides for limits including urgency, certain exceptional circumstances and a special adversarial procedure set by legislation. Check whether the decision gives facts supporting the branch relied on. French Code on Relations Between the Public and the Administration, art. L121-2 |
Swiss law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
Which federal authority issued the withdrawal? | Record the authority, legal basis and type of decision, then check the scope under Swiss federal article 1. Keep any cantonal route separate, since different rules may apply to the body that issued the permit. Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 1 |
What allegation affected the decision? | Copy the decisive statement about P-17 and compare it with the earlier notice about a processing concern. Under article 29 the parties have a right to be heard. Check when the file shows that the holder could address P-17. Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 29 |
When could the holder address it? | Look for a dated invitation that identifies the incident, any reply and its receipt before the 17 November decision. Article 30 provides for a prior hearing in the general case. Confirm the actual opportunity to respond from those papers. Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 30 |
Does a stated exception affect the hearing right? | Check the exact exception in article 30(2) and whether its facts are documented. For urgency under letter e, the conditions also concern the availability of an appeal and the absence of another federal right to a prior hearing. Swiss Federal Administrative Procedure Act, art. 30 |
How was the Swiss hearing rule checked?
On 21 November 2026, a signed local test requested articles 29 and 30 from the read-only French corpus of Swiss federal law, RS 172.021.
The local reference service returned a nonempty passage for each requested article. This test covered source lookup and retrieval in that environment.
Common questions
France: What factual ground does the decision give?
In the example, the notice concerns a processing issue and the final decision relies on incident P-17. Record the difference and when P-17 was disclosed. For a covered withdrawal, this matters to the opportunity for prior submissions.
France: Was there a chance to give written observations?
Read the invitation to respond, the date received and the actual deadline. Under article L122-1, where applicable, the holder has an opportunity for written observations and in relevant cases may request oral observations.
France: Is a statutory exception or special procedure identified?
Identify the stated exception and its legal basis. French article L121-2 provides for limits including urgency, certain exceptional circumstances and a special adversarial procedure set by legislation. Check whether the decision gives facts supporting the branch relied on.
Switzerland: Which federal authority issued the withdrawal?
Record the authority, legal basis and type of decision, then check the scope under Swiss federal article 1. Keep any cantonal route separate, since different rules may apply to the body that issued the permit.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.