France and Switzerland
A foundation can no longer carry out its purpose
In France, a substantial purpose change for a recognized public-interest foundation requires the applicable public approval. Swiss law distinguishes changing the purpose under its statutory conditions from dissolution when it can no longer be achieved. Compare the approved purpose, evidence of the obstacle and the exact amendment before submitting it.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Compare the French approved purpose with the board’s proposal
| Approved programme and beneficiaries | Public-interest programme at the only approved location |
|---|---|
| Event, alternative and drafting change | Site unavailable. Board proposes another programme for the same population. |
| Board resolution and authority decision to verify | Compare the proposed wording and the substantial-change approval path. |
Fictional example. The approved site is lost and the board suggests a different programme for the same beneficiaries. Verify the necessary approval route.
Swiss law
Compare the Swiss deed, founder’s intent and continuation options
| Purpose in the deed and founder’s intent | Programme tied to the only approved site |
|---|---|
| Documented interruption and proposed purpose | Site cannot be used. New activity for the same population proposed. |
| Application and preservation evidence | Check the supreme body’s resolution and the competent federal or cantonal authority. |
Fictional example. The site is unavailable. Check whether the original purpose can be preserved or whether a formal change is required.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
What purpose appears in the approved public-benefit foundation charter? | Locate the French recognition decree and approved charter. Copy the exact public-benefit purpose, the programme and the intended beneficiaries. Article 18 describes the foundation’s permanent dedication of assets to its public-interest purpose. French Patronage Act of 23 July 1987, art. 18 |
What evidence shows that the programme can no longer operate? | Keep evidence showing when the site became unavailable and why the approved programme could not continue there. Identify whether the existing purpose could still be carried out another way under the present charter. Service Public, amendment of a recognised public-benefit foundation charter |
Does the draft change the purpose substantially? | Compare the exact French old and proposed clauses. A new programme can change the purpose even if the same people benefit. Determine whether the proposal concerns a substantial change to purpose or endowment. Service Public, amendment of a recognised public-benefit foundation charter |
Which sovereign approval route applies to the actual draft? | For a substantial French purpose or endowment amendment, the published route is a decree after Conseil d’État advice. A non-substantial amendment follows a ministerial order after advice. Identify which draft the board actually approved to submit. Service Public, amendment of a recognised public-benefit foundation charter |
Swiss law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
How have the original purpose and founder’s intent diverged? | For Switzerland, compare the original purpose and the founder’s documented intentions. Article 86 requires a change in character or scope so significant that the foundation manifestly no longer reflects those intentions. Swiss Civil Code, art. 86 |
What evidence shows the programme cannot continue? | Collect the dated Swiss records showing loss of the approved site and the effect on the programme. Record whether another location or means could fulfil the purpose in the deed. Match the evidence to the actual activity. Swiss Civil Code, art. 80 |
Who can seek amendment and who decides? | Under Swiss article 86, the supervisory authority or supreme body can request a purpose change and the competent federal or cantonal authority decides. Verify whether the proposal is substantial or an ancillary adjustment under article 86b. Swiss Civil Code, art. 86 |
Can the foundation still be maintained by changing the deed? | Examine whether the Swiss foundation could be preserved through a deed amendment. Article 88 addresses an unattainable purpose together with inability to preserve it by amendment. Document the options and any separate decision. Swiss Civil Code, art. 88 |
Common questions
France: What evidence shows that the programme can no longer operate?
Keep evidence showing when the site became unavailable and why the approved programme could not continue there. Identify whether the existing purpose could still be carried out another way under the present charter.
France: Does the draft change the purpose substantially?
Compare the exact French old and proposed clauses. A new programme can change the purpose even if the same people benefit. Determine whether the proposal concerns a substantial change to purpose or endowment.
France: Which sovereign approval route applies to the actual draft?
For a substantial French purpose or endowment amendment, the published route is a decree after Conseil d’État advice. A non-substantial amendment follows a ministerial order after advice. Identify which draft the board actually approved to submit.
Switzerland: How have the original purpose and founder’s intent diverged?
For Switzerland, compare the original purpose and the founder’s documented intentions. Article 86 requires a change in character or scope so significant that the foundation manifestly no longer reflects those intentions.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.