France and Switzerland
Supplier says silence accepted a new order
In France, silence generally does not accept an offer, although established dealings or particular circumstances can affect the result. Switzerland considers whether express acceptance could reasonably be expected and whether there was timely refusal. Compare the disputed order, earlier dealings and any positive act before relying on silence.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Compare the claimed ordering practice with the documented one
| Supplier’s description of earlier approvals | Orders released with no confirmation |
|---|---|
| Approval method shown in earlier order records | Written buyer confirmation required |
The sample accounts differ. Look for dated confirmation messages for several comparable orders.
Swiss law
Put the Swiss receipt, reply and handling dates in order
| Offer received by the ordering contact | 2026-10-06 |
|---|---|
| Rejection delivered to the supplier | 2026-10-08 |
| Supplier’s reported dispatch | 2026-10-09 |
Compare the timeline with the actual ordering practice before assessing what period for refusal could be suitable.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
Which actual offer and deadline does the latest exchange identify? | Find the message and attachment the supplier calls the latest offer. Record the order reference, quantity, price, recipient and any date it asks for a decision. Distinguish a concrete proposal from a price enquiry or a reminder of earlier negotiations. French Civil Code, article 1120, silence and exceptions |
What previous business practice is relied upon as an exception to silence? | Ask what the supplier says made silence count. Article 1120 identifies exceptions involving law, usage, business relations or particular circumstances. Gather the communications the supplier relies on and compare their dates and scope with the new proposal before treating a past relationship as enough. French Civil Code, article 1120, silence and exceptions |
Did the earlier orders actually require confirmation? | Build a short record of comparable previous orders. Note whether they were released after a signed order, a confirmation email or without any reply. Preserve any instructions showing that confirmation was required, including changes to staff or approval processes before the latest order. French Civil Code, article 1120, silence and exceptions |
Is any unequivocal conduct being asserted separately? | Check whether the supplier relies on a payment, instruction to ship or use of the goods as an affirmative act. Connect the evidence to the specific new offer. Evaluate any asserted clear conduct separately from the argument that silence alone took effect under the exception. French Civil Code, article 1120, silence and exceptions |
Swiss law
| Question | Answer and sources |
|---|---|
Could the offeror reasonably have expected express acceptance in these circumstances? | Check the nature of the transaction and what each side knew about the ordering routine. Under Swiss article 6, the absence of rejection in a suitable time matters where express acceptance should not have been expected. Repeated written confirmations can be significant evidence of a different expectation. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 1 and 6, assent and special circumstances |
When was the offer received and when, if ever, did rejection arrive? | Record when the proposal actually reached the relevant recipient and when any rejection reached the offeror. Keep the message, delivery trail and any acknowledgement. A refusal prepared internally and a refusal transmitted through the usual ordering channel have different evidential weight. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 1 and 6, assent and special circumstances |
What evidence bears on a suitable refusal period? | Use the transaction type, proposed starting date, complexity and established way of replying to assess the circumstances. Article 6 refers to a suitable period for rejection in the particular case. Preserve timestamps and avoid assuming every order has the same period. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 1 and 6, assent and special circumstances |
Were prior order acceptance and performance consistent with the claimed practice? | Compare the parties, terms, confirmation and conduct in representative earlier transactions. Separate actual acceptance, whether expressed or shown by conduct under article 1, from the special absence-of-rejection rule under article 6. There may be a new price or quantity that weakens the comparison. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 1 and 6, assent and special circumstances |
Which concrete discrepancy should the reply identify? | Identify the specific mismatch in the response, such as written confirmation having been required for all earlier orders. Attach the correspondence, point to the changed quantity or terms, and state whether a rejection was actually sent. Ask for the evidence behind the claimed ordering practice. Swiss Code of Obligations, articles 1 and 6, assent and special circumstances |
Common questions
France — What previous business practice is relied upon as an exception to silence?
Ask what the supplier says made silence count. Article 1120 identifies exceptions involving law, usage, business relations or particular circumstances. Gather the communications the supplier relies on and compare their dates and scope with the new proposal before treating a past relationship as enough.
France — Did the earlier orders actually require confirmation?
Build a short record of comparable previous orders. Note whether they were released after a signed order, a confirmation email or without any reply. Preserve any instructions showing that confirmation was required, including changes to staff or approval processes before the latest order.
France — Is any unequivocal conduct being asserted separately?
Check whether the supplier relies on a payment, instruction to ship or use of the goods as an affirmative act. Connect the evidence to the specific new offer. Evaluate any asserted clear conduct separately from the argument that silence alone took effect under the exception.
Switzerland — Could the offeror reasonably have expected express acceptance in these circumstances?
Check the nature of the transaction and what each side knew about the ordering routine. Under Swiss article 6, the absence of rejection in a suitable time matters where express acceptance should not have been expected. Repeated written confirmations can be significant evidence of a different expectation.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.