France and Switzerland
Restricting public access to a civil hearing
In France, a civil court can sit in chambers where publicity would intrude on private life. Switzerland allows partial or full exclusion of the public where the public interest or a participant’s protectable interest requires it. Point to the actual scheduled hearing and the particular part for which you seek protection.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Which approval is still needed for the French hearing segment?
| Hearing segment and private interest | Segment and interest documented |
|---|---|
| Court decision on public attendance | Decision or attendance scope pending |
The example identifies segment B of an ordinary civil hearing as involving a private issue. The next record is the court’s decision about that segment and public attendance.
Swiss law
What has the Swiss court decided about attendance?
| Protectable interest and part of the hearing | Interest and segment documented |
|---|---|
| Court decision and exact attendance scope | Decision or scope still pending |
The example request covers one segment of a normally public hearing. It identifies the participant’s interest but the court’s decision and attendance scope are still missing.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
Which court and usually public hearing are identified?
Identify the French court, case, hearing and the rules of publicity that apply to the proceeding. Keep the notice that sets the date.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 435What private issue is expected to be aired?
Identify the private issue and explain how discussing it in public would interfere with private life. Record the category of information and its location in the hearing.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 435Is the requested in-camera treatment limited to the relevant part?
Describe the part of the French proceedings that the request should cover. Article 435 allows the judge to order that proceedings take place or continue in chambers on the stated grounds.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 435What judge determination remains to be checked?
Check whether the judge has ruled on the request and what the ruling covers. Follow the attendance instructions actually issued for the hearing.
French Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 435Swiss law
Which court and proceeding are on the summons?
Record the Swiss cantonal court, case and hearing from the summons. Article 54 normally provides for public hearings, with a separate rule for family proceedings.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 54 (SR 272)What participant interest requires protection?
Identify the participant’s protectable interest or the public interest at stake. Explain how public discussion of the identified matter would affect that interest.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 54 (SR 272)Would limited exclusion address the issue?
Article 54 allows full or partial exclusion of the public where the relevant interest requires it. Identify the segment concerned and whether the narrower request would protect it.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 54 (SR 272)What exact court decision and attendance scope need confirmation?
Check the Swiss court’s decision and the exact attendance arrangement. Access to the case file and to a judgment can raise separate questions.
Swiss Civil Procedure Code, Art. 54 (SR 272)Common questions
France — What private issue is expected to be aired?
Identify the private issue and explain how discussing it in public would interfere with private life. Record the category of information and its location in the hearing.
France — Is the requested in-camera treatment limited to the relevant part?
Describe the part of the French proceedings that the request should cover. Article 435 allows the judge to order that proceedings take place or continue in chambers on the stated grounds.
France — What judge determination remains to be checked?
Check whether the judge has ruled on the request and what the ruling covers. Follow the attendance instructions actually issued for the hearing.
Switzerland — Which court and proceeding are on the summons?
Record the Swiss cantonal court, case and hearing from the summons. Article 54 normally provides for public hearings, with a separate rule for family proceedings.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.