France and Switzerland
A refused legacy names an alternate beneficiary
French law recognizes a testamentary designation for the case in which a named beneficiary does not take. Swiss law expressly addresses substitutes for refusal of a legacy. Compare the dated refusal and exact item with the clause naming the alternate, and record any independent inheritance entitlement separately.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
France · document refusal, alternate and delivery
| Will and alternate clause | 2026-03-12 |
|---|---|
| Signed refusal of the watch | 2026-09-22 |
| Scope of refusal | Watch legacy only |
| Allocation and delivery | Alternate entered, delivery to confirm |
Fictional example. The refusal identifies only the watch legacy. The executor names the alternate. Check the distinct heir’s share and the actual transfer.
Swiss law
Switzerland · match the refused legacy to the substitute provision
| Will with substitute disposition | 2026-03-12 |
|---|---|
| Repudiation of the watch legacy | 2026-09-22 |
| Scope and separate role | Watch only, legal heir status separate |
| Proposed recipient and transfer | Substitute in the draft, obtain receipt |
Fictional example. The will provides a substitute if the watch is refused. The signed refusal identifies the watch. Check the separate heir status and delivery.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
Which one legacy and refusal are evidenced?
For France, keep the will identifying the watch and the dated signed refusal. Verify that the declaration concerns this legacy and use the inventory to match the item.
French Civil Code, Article 1043 — repudiationDoes the will expressly name an alternate for refusal?
Read the operative French will for a beneficiary named if the first legatee does not take. Check the actual wording and whether the documented refusal satisfies the clause.
French Civil Code, Article 898 — alternate dispositionWhat separately held vocation is documented, if any?
Identify any separate legal heir’s share and its evidence. Article 769 provides a distinct option for each vocation where several apply. Keep the exercise of each option separate.
French Civil Code, Article 769 — separate inheritance optionsWhat allocation remains to be checked?
Compare the alternate named in the French will with the executor’s proposed allocation for the watch. Obtain the actual delivery or final allocation record.
French Civil Code, Article 898 — alternate dispositionSwiss law
Which legacy was repudiated and by what act?
For Switzerland, obtain the signed declaration identifying only the watch legacy, with date and delivery evidence. Check who received it and when.
Swiss Civil Code, Article 577 — refusal of a legacyWhat secondary disposition expressly controls?
The Swiss provision can name a substitute if the first legatee refuses. Compare the words used in the will, the item and the person named with the document showing refusal.
Swiss Civil Code, Article 487 — substitute beneficiaryWhat default would apply absent contrary intent?
In the absence of a contrary intention, refusal benefits the person required to perform the legacy under Article 577. Verify the will before using that default.
Swiss Civil Code, Article 577 — refusal of a legacyWhich role or transfer proof is still needed?
Check the successor’s distinct legal role and obtain the inventory and delivery record for the watch. An executor’s allocation entry identifies the proposed recipient and the remaining proof.
Swiss Civil Code, Article 484 — legacyCommon questions
France — Does the will expressly name an alternate for refusal?
Read the operative French will for a beneficiary named if the first legatee does not take. Check the actual wording and whether the documented refusal satisfies the clause.
France — What separately held vocation is documented, if any?
Identify any separate legal heir’s share and its evidence. Article 769 provides a distinct option for each vocation where several apply. Keep the exercise of each option separate.
France — What allocation remains to be checked?
Compare the alternate named in the French will with the executor’s proposed allocation for the watch. Obtain the actual delivery or final allocation record.
Switzerland — Which legacy was repudiated and by what act?
For Switzerland, obtain the signed declaration identifying only the watch legacy, with date and delivery evidence. Check who received it and when.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.