Records · procedure · next step
Prison discipline: organise defence and decision records
Prison-discipline preparation separates the incident report, decision to prosecute, defence access, hearing and sanction. France’s penitentiary procedure differs from Swiss federal/cantonal arrangements; preventive placement is not automatically a merits decision. Preserve versions, requests and actual notifications. This dossier does not determine guilt, promise a sanction outcome or apply employment discipline rules to detention. Missing evidence remains a question for the actual proceeding.
General information and document preparation. The facts, actual procedural acts and applicable versions must be checked.
Julie’s legal research currently covers French law. The Swiss sections prepare documents; they do not establish Swiss-law product capability.
Julie by AlphaDeep
Let’s link allegations, defence requests and the actual decision. Julie currently handles French law; Swiss preparation remains documentary.
3 free questions at signup. Avoid names and sensitive information.
Prepare the records
Julie’s legal research currently covers French law. The Swiss sections prepare documents; they do not establish Swiss-law product capability.
Synthetic example
Incident-defence-decision review chronology
- Incident/chronology
- Fictitious I1 ; times missing
- Report/prosecution
- R1 ; P1 absent
- Notice/hearing
- N1 not supplied
- Counsel/access
- Requests undocumented
- Useful records
- Video reference V1 unclear
- Preventive measure
- No act supplied
- Sanction/reasons
- Not received
- Review/receipt
- Dates unknown
This record organises supplied documents and values; it certifies no entitlement, permission or safety.
Which French record distinguishes report and prosecution ?
R. 234-14 concerns the governor/delegate’s prosecution decision after reports, within its stated discovery limit. The incident report is not the sanction.
Which French notice and preparation evidence matters ?
R. 234-15 identifies allegations, legal character, hearing date/time and at least twenty-four hours for defence. Keep actual communication and timing.
How are French counsel, file and video requests documented ?
R. 234-16/17 provide qualified assistance/access and specifically identified useful material under their limits. Preserve requests and responses rather than assuming unrestricted access.
What French act separates prevention, sanction and prior review ?
L. 231-2/R. 234-19 concern prevention; R. 234-43 requires the specified prior administrative appeal against sanction. Keep each decision and notification.
What Swiss framework depends on custody status ?
CP/StGB/CP 91 concerns culpable breach and cantonal discipline in sentence execution; CPP/StPO/CPP 235 reserves local procedural-detention rules.
What Geneva Champ-Dollon defence record is relevant ?
Current RRIP 47 requires allegations, hearing, proportionate sanction and the applicable competence. Retain the actual provision and act instead of an old judgment’s former sanction list.
How do Geneva REPSD establishments differ ?
REPSD 46 has its own hearing, governor and delegation provisions for named institutions. It is not interchangeable with Champ-Dollon’s RRIP.
Which Swiss review authority should be identified ?
Geneva RRIP 59/LaCP 30 and REPSD 49 separate routes by status and act. Preserve actual sanction, author and communication before assigning a forum.
Frequently asked questions
Which French record distinguishes report and prosecution ?
R. 234-14 concerns the governor/delegate’s prosecution decision after reports, within its stated discovery limit. The incident report is not the sanction.
How are French counsel, file and video requests documented ?
R. 234-16/17 provide qualified assistance/access and specifically identified useful material under their limits. Preserve requests and responses rather than assuming unrestricted access.
What Geneva Champ-Dollon defence record is relevant ?
Current RRIP 47 requires allegations, hearing, proportionate sanction and the applicable competence. Retain the actual provision and act instead of an old judgment’s former sanction list.
Which Swiss review authority should be identified ?
Geneva RRIP 59/LaCP 30 and REPSD 49 separate routes by status and act. Preserve actual sanction, author and communication before assigning a forum.
Sources and versions
- ch-cp-fr
2026-11-01
- ch-cpp-fr
2025-04-01
- ch-ge-la-cp
2024-01-26
- ch-ge-repsd
2025-01-31
- ch-ge-rrip
2026-01-22
- fr-penit-L231-2
- fr-penit-R234-14
- fr-penit-R234-15
- fr-penit-R234-16
- fr-penit-R234-17
- fr-penit-R234-19
- fr-penit-R234-43