France and Switzerland
A carrier seeks recourse after paying a freight claim
In France, a carrier’s separate guarantee recourse can have a clock that starts with the original action. In Switzerland, the contracting carrier can have recourse against the carrier to which it handed the goods. Identify that party and reconcile the paid claim against the particular handover and alleged shortage.
See the records to compareSources checked on
French law
Trace the French action, cargo loss payment and separate charge
| Initial court action against A | 2026-11-04 |
|---|---|
| Partial indemnity paid by A | 2026-11-12 |
| Separate charge and overlap to verify | EUR 3,800 settled on 12 November. Compare B’s EUR 1,100 allocation with the same loss. |
Fictional example. The customer’s action predates the partial payment. Identify the overlap claimed by B and check the French recourse trigger.
Swiss law
Match Swiss payment and recourse to the documented leg
| Customer’s claim commenced | 2026-11-04 |
|---|---|
| A's documented payment | 2026-11-12 |
| Allocation, handover and remaining issue | CHF 3,800 paid, CHF 1,100 in B’s statement. Identify any overlap and the date of delivery for article 454. |
Fictional example. A pays part of the client claim and B provides a separate allocation. Check handover, scope of each amount and the applicable time limit.
Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.
French law
What cargo was passed to the subcontracted carrier?
Match the French subcontract and handover receipt to the cargo, seal and identifiers passed from A to B. Identify the domestic leg and any applicable written terms or standard provisions.
French Transport Code, annex II, general standard contract, art. 1When was the original action first exercised?
Keep the French initial action and its evidence. The example dates it 4 November. Where article L133-6’s recourse rule applies, identify the actual action against the party seeking guarantee before starting the clock.
French Commercial Code, art. L133-6What portion of the paid amount relates to the cargo loss?
Reconcile the French partial settlement and the EUR 3,800 paid with the specific cargo loss. Compare B’s EUR 1,100 allocation against the same items, identifying any duplicate and distinct charges.
French Commercial Code, art. L133-1Which route and recourse time limit apply?
Check the independent French recourse basis and the one-month period under article L133-6 if applicable. It runs from the action against the guaranteed party. Keep the payment date separate when reviewing the deadline.
French Commercial Code, art. L133-6Swiss law
To which carrier did the first carrier hand over the goods?
For Switzerland, identify the immediate carrier to whom A handed the cargo. Article 449 addresses recourse against that carrier. Confirm the actual receipt and the goods handed over.
Swiss Code of Obligations, art. 449Which separate carriage undertaking was accepted?
Read the Swiss subcontract, accepted leg and agreed scope. Compare these with the handover receipt and evidence of the incident. A settlement upstream does not determine the claim under the second contract.
Swiss Code of Obligations, art. 449What evidence links the amount paid to that leg?
Match the Swiss payment record, settlement and loss items to the relevant cargo and route. Check B’s separate allocation for overlap. Article 447 supplies the loss framework and relevant defences in its scope.
Swiss Code of Obligations, art. 447Which contract and procedural rule still govern recovery?
For a Swiss damages claim within article 454, check the applicable actual or expected delivery date and exceptions. Identify the specific contract and procedural rule governing the recourse before calculating any deadline.
Swiss Code of Obligations, art. 454Common questions
France — When was the original action first exercised?
Keep the French initial action and its evidence. The example dates it 4 November. Where article L133-6’s recourse rule applies, identify the actual action against the party seeking guarantee before starting the clock.
France — What portion of the paid amount relates to the cargo loss?
Reconcile the French partial settlement and the EUR 3,800 paid with the specific cargo loss. Compare B’s EUR 1,100 allocation against the same items, identifying any duplicate and distinct charges.
France — Which route and recourse time limit apply?
Check the independent French recourse basis and the one-month period under article L133-6 if applicable. It runs from the action against the guaranteed party. Keep the payment date separate when reviewing the deadline.
Switzerland — To which carrier did the first carrier hand over the goods?
For Switzerland, identify the immediate carrier to whom A handed the cargo. Article 449 addresses recourse against that carrier. Confirm the actual receipt and the goods handed over.
General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.