Records · procedure · next step
Statutory audit report: management response records
An audit-response dossier starts with the signed report, period, framework and actual opinion. Link each finding to supporting evidence, a proposed correction, management response and auditor follow-up. French statutory-audit and Swiss ordinary/limited-audit reports have different scopes. The record does not change a signed opinion, set materiality, certify accounts or treat management’s response as auditor acceptance.
General information and document preparation. The facts, actual procedural acts and applicable versions must be checked.
Julie’s legal research currently covers French law. The Swiss sections prepare documents; they do not establish Swiss-law product capability.
Julie by AlphaDeep
Which country and signed audit report are involved? Julie currently researches French law.
3 free questions at signup. Avoid names and sensitive information.
| Document question | Reference and records to compare |
|---|---|
France: which report is being answered? | L. 821-53 identifies annual/consolidated certification. Preserve the signed report, period and actual scope rather than an internal meeting summary. |
France: does every remark qualify the opinion? | Audit directive article 28 distinguishes opinion, inability, emphasis and going-concern matters. Keep the actual wording and attribution. |
Prepare the records
Julie’s legal research currently covers French law. The Swiss sections prepare documents; they do not establish Swiss-law product capability.
Synthetic example
Finding-evidence-management response and auditor follow-up matrix
- Report
- Synthetic R1; signed copy missing
- Framework
- P1 period; accounting basis unknown
- Opinion
- O1 wording not supplied
- Finding
- C1 asserted missing balance support
- Recipient
- G1; actual governance role unresolved
- Evidence
- E1; copy/link absent
- Response
- Draft V2; correction unaccepted
- Follow-up
- No auditor closure supplied
This record organises supplied documents and values; it certifies no entitlement, permission or safety.
| Document question | Reference and records to compare |
|---|---|
France: what should each response link? | L. 821-63 concerns governance communications, findings and proposed changes. Keep a distinct finding, evidence, response version and actual follow-up. |
France: does audit guarantee management quality? | L. 821-54/55 limits the financial mission and rejects a viability/management-quality guarantee. The preparation record adds no certification. |
Switzerland: which ordinary-audit reports differ? | CO 728b distinguishes detailed board report and general-meeting summary. Record the actual recipient, scope and signature. |
Switzerland: what if the auditor issued a warning? | CO 728c has written board warning and escalation branches. Keep the actual notice and response, with overindebtedness duties separate. |
Switzerland: is limited audit the same opinion? | CO 729b requires its limited nature and disclosures. Do not recast that report as an ordinary-audit assurance. |
Switzerland: what evidence and confidentiality limits apply? | CO 730b concerns supplied information and confidentiality/disclosure. Track requests and responses without claiming unlimited third-party access or accepted correction. |
Frequently asked questions
France: which report is being answered?
L. 821-53 identifies annual/consolidated certification. Preserve the signed report, period and actual scope rather than an internal meeting summary.
France: what should each response link?
L. 821-63 concerns governance communications, findings and proposed changes. Keep a distinct finding, evidence, response version and actual follow-up.
Switzerland: what if the auditor issued a warning?
CO 728c has written board warning and escalation branches. Keep the actual notice and response, with overindebtedness duties separate.
Switzerland: what evidence and confidentiality limits apply?
CO 730b concerns supplied information and confidentiality/disclosure. Track requests and responses without claiming unlimited third-party access or accepted correction.