Julie

Votre espace se prépare…

Preparing your space…

Le chargement prend plus de temps que prévu.
Réessayer
Loading is taking longer than expected.
Try again
Skip to main content

France and Switzerland

First liability claim after switching insurers

In France, liability cover can be triggered by the damaging event or the claim under the applicable statutory rules. In Switzerland, begin with the actual trigger and time clauses in each policy. Record the act, knowledge and first claim, then compare prior-acts cover and any coverage continuing after the first policy ended.

See the records to compare

Sources checked on

Choose the applicable law to prepare your question.

French law

Sequence the French loss, insurer change and claim

Fictional example
Date of the alleged harmful act2026-05-12
Date the new insurance took effect2026-07-01
Date of receipt of the first claim2026-08-18
Trigger clauses for the two policiesPrevious act trigger, new claims trigger

The fictional act in May precedes the July switch and the August claim. Use the actual trigger terms to determine what needs checking.

Swiss law

Order Swiss policy dates, discovery and claim

Fictional example
Documented date of the alleged act2026-05-12
Date of the change of Swiss policy2026-07-01
Receipt date of the first liability claim2026-08-18
Relevant definitions to comparePrior occurrence clause and current claims-made or known circumstances wording

Use the fictional timeline and each policy’s actual definition of its trigger. Check prior acts, known circumstances and any run-off terms.

Julie by AlphaDeep is an AI legal assistant for preparing questions, reviewing documents and finding official sources for the law it covers.

French law

QuestionAnswer and sources

What wording and effective dates identify each professional liability policy?

Identify the insured, professional activity, effective dates and temporal terms for each French policy. Keep the complete policies and any endorsements. Article L124-5 distinguishes the act and claim triggers and preserves other statutory time-coverage regimes.

French Insurance Code, article L124-5, coverage over time

When did the harmful act occur and when was it known?

Record the alleged harmful act date and when the insured learned of it. Keep separate proof for each. For claims-trigger coverage under article L124-5, knowledge at inception and certain circumstances after an earlier expiry can affect which guarantee applies.

French Insurance Code, article L124-5, coverage over time

When and to whom was the first claim sent?

Identify the first actual third-party claim, who received it and when. Preserve the original complaint, correspondence and delivery evidence. Compare it with each policy’s effective dates and any applicable subsequent period, separating it from an earlier internal awareness of the problem.

French Insurance Code, article L124-5, coverage over time

Do both policies potentially respond and does the statutory priority apply?

Read the French official model for an old act-trigger policy followed by a claims-trigger policy. Check if the act occurred in the earlier covered period and whether the claims-based cover could also respond. Under article L124-5, qualifying act-trigger coverage receives priority when the same loss can engage both successive contracts.

French Insurance Code, appendix to article A112, model for switching policies

Swiss law

QuestionAnswer and sources

Which temporal trigger and transition wording does each actual policy adopt?

For Switzerland, read each policy’s actual trigger and transition clauses. The Federal Supreme Court’s 4A_503/2023 reasons discuss attribution by act, loss or its discovery, and claims made. Use those concepts to classify the actual words rather than assigning the new insurer by claim date alone.

Swiss Federal Supreme Court, 4A_503/2023, reasons in German

When did the relevant act, loss or first claim occur?

Reconstruct the dates of the act, the loss or its established discovery, and the first demand. Keep a separate date for the insured’s knowledge of circumstances. Determine which event matters under each policy before comparing the timeline to the policy periods.

Swiss Federal Supreme Court, 4A_503/2023, reasons in German

Is there an applicable known-circumstances or run-off clause?

Check clauses for past acts, known circumstances and reporting after the former term. The specific successive-policy case 4A_433/2025 interpreted prior-risk wording and existing cover under earlier provisions. Compare the contracts and evidence of knowledge instead of treating that outcome as an automatic transfer rule.

Swiss Federal Supreme Court, 4A_433/2025, successive policy wording

Does a special mandatory regime matter?

Check whether the activity and risk are subject to a compulsory or other special insurance regime. Article 3 addresses information on temporal validity, and article 10 concerns retroactive insurance. Identify the governing text and contract terms for this particular liability instead of applying the French allocation rule.

Swiss Insurance Contract Act, articles 3, 10 and 100

Which documents show how each chronology should be presented?

For the Swiss file, send the dated act and claim records, insurer notices, all operative policy clauses and the earlier report evidence if relevant. Label uncertain dates. Ask for the trigger, past-risk or run-off wording each insurer relied on and what other evidence it needs.

Swiss Federal Supreme Court, 4A_503/2023, reasons in German

Common questions

France — When did the harmful act occur and when was it known?

Record the alleged harmful act date and when the insured learned of it. Keep separate proof for each. For claims-trigger coverage under article L124-5, knowledge at inception and certain circumstances after an earlier expiry can affect which guarantee applies.

France — When and to whom was the first claim sent?

Identify the first actual third-party claim, who received it and when. Preserve the original complaint, correspondence and delivery evidence. Compare it with each policy’s effective dates and any applicable subsequent period, separating it from an earlier internal awareness of the problem.

France — Do both policies potentially respond and does the statutory priority apply?

Read the French official model for an old act-trigger policy followed by a claims-trigger policy. Check if the act occurred in the earlier covered period and whether the claims-based cover could also respond. Under article L124-5, qualifying act-trigger coverage receives priority when the same loss can engage both successive contracts.

Switzerland — Which temporal trigger and transition wording does each actual policy adopt?

For Switzerland, read each policy’s actual trigger and transition clauses. The Federal Supreme Court’s 4A_503/2023 reasons discuss attribution by act, loss or its discovery, and claims made. Use those concepts to classify the actual words rather than assigning the new insurer by claim date alone.

General legal information and preparation tools. Consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your situation.